Close Announcement Bar Welcome to the new Cape May County Association of Realtors Web Site!
Cape May County Association of Realtors
HOME     PROPERTY SEARCH     SELECT A REALTOR     CONTACT  
ABOUTDrop Down Arrow     BUYERS & SELLERSDrop Down Arrow     RENTALSDrop Down Arrow     NEW MEMBER FORMS
124 W New York Avenue - Picture 1
Arrow Left Arrow Right

124 W New York Avenue, Villas - ACTIVE

For Sale: $525,000

MLS: 260750       Beds: 2       Baths: 1       Type: Single Family
Lot: 90x100       DOM: 2 Days



Set on an oversized 90x100 double lot backing to a private wooded area, this one-of-a-kind beach home offers rare space, privacy, and endless potential for future expansion just steps from the beach at the end of the block. Known as The Pink Lady in Key West, this fully renovated, designer-curated home delivers a vibrant coastal lifestyle unlike anything else in the area. Completely gutted and reimagined in 2021 2022 by a professional interior designer, every detail was thoughtfully selected to create a bright, beachy bungalow feel with bold colors and a true vacation vibe from the moment you arrive. The exterior welcomes you with custom hardscaping featuring white shell landscaping, a unique driveway, half-moon stepping stones, and coastal-inspired accents including pilings and marine rope, all complemented by thoughtfully selected landscaping suited for the shore environment. The serene wooded backdrop enhances the sense of privacy and relaxation rarely found this close to the beach. Inside, the home is move-in ready and offered fully furnished and fully stocked, making it ideal as a primary residence, second home, or turnkey rental investment. Recent upgrades include luxury vinyl plank flooring, a beautifully updated kitchen with white quartz countertops and freshly painted cabinetry, high-end fixtures, a renovated bathroom with custom tile, updated lighting and ceiling fans, a newer washer and dryer, new deck boards, and a new heater installed in 2026. The crawl space has been fully encapsulated with a sump pump and French drain system, and the property was regraded with extensive hardscaping and landscaping completed between 2021 and 2024. Furnishings include custom-designed drapes, a sleeper sectional, a Bernhardt upholstered bed with a Tempur-Pedic mattress, and stylish vintage bamboo dining and bedroom pieces. The kitchen comes fully equipped, and the shed is stocked with bikes, beach chairs, and additional beach gear. Active service contracts are in place for the crawlspace, HVAC, and pest prevention, and the owners are willing to share trusted vendor contacts. A rare opportunity to own a spacious, fully furnished designer beach retreat with room to grow in a highly desirable location.
AMENITIES
  • Range   
  • Oven   
  • Microwave Oven   
  • Refrigerator   
  • Washer   
  • Dryer   
  • Dishwasher   
  • Disposal   
  • Stove Natural Gas   
  • Stainless steel appliance   
  • Deck   
  • Fenced Yard   
  • Storage Building   
  • Living Room   
  • Kitchen   
  • Eat-In-Kitchen   
  • Dining Area   
  • Laundry/Utility Room   
  • Storage Attic   
  • Heating:Gas Natural   
  • Heating:Forced Air   
  • Heater:Electric  
  • Vinyl Flooring  
  • Cooling:Central Air Condition  
  • City  
  • Ranch  
PROPERTY LOCATION / MAP
Last Database Update: 04/19/2026 04:00:35
Listing is provided by eXp REALTY, Jason Ruffenach, 866-201-6210. The data relating to real estate for sale on this web page appears in part through the Cape May County MLS program, a voluntary cooperative exchange of property listing data between licensed real estate brokerage firms in which we participate, and is provided by Cape May County MLS through a licensing agreement. Disclaimer: All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified. All properties are subject to change, withdrawal, or prior sale.
CMCAR
New Jersey Realtors   National Association of Realtors   Home Ownership Matters
REALTOR® -- A registered collective membership mark that identifies a real estate professional who is a member of the National Association of REALTORS®
and subscribes to its strict Code of Ethics. Inquiries regarding the Code of Ethics should be directed to the board in which a REALTOR® holds membership.
Address Instagram Facebook YouTube Office

DMCA

PRIVACY POLICY

HOME
PROPERTY SEARCH
SELECT A REALTOR
NEW MEMBER FORMS
CONTACT US
SITE MAP
ADMIN
ABOUT
- Mission Statement
- Bylaws & Policies
- Strategic Plan
- CMCAR® Leadership
CMCMLS Leadership
- Our Team
- Code of Ethics
- Directions
BUYERS & SELLERS
- FAQ
- Consumer Resources
- Market Information
- Home Services Directory
- News, Reports & Press
RENTALS
- Year Round Rentals
- Weekly Rentals
MEMBERS
- Calendar / Events
- Membership Applications
- News, Reports & Press
© Cape May County Association of REALTORS®
- All Rights Reserved.
Web Site Designed By: Square 1 Design